Unsubscribe
View in your browser
 
Adjudication Society Newsletter, Summer 2025
Newsletter contents

Editors' Notes - Douglas James, 4 New Square

Size Matters - Gareth Williams

In All Tenderbids - James O’Donoghue and Arran Dowling-Hussey

VAT in adjudication - John Littler

Placefirst - Jim Armstrong

Adjudicators' Entitlement to Fees - Julian Critchlow

Argue Now, Pay Later - Nick Kaplan

When 7-days actually means 6-days... - Seán Bradley

Adapt or Walk Away? Rethinking Force Majeure in a World of Disruption - S. Walemba, M. Cookson and K. Kenneally

Case Notes

Construction Law - Professor John Uff CBE KC

The Law of Net Zero and Nature Positive - N. Pleming et al.

Building Women - Faye Allen

13th Case Law Update - Carly Thorpe

Is the Adjudication Process Unfair? - Panel Discussion

Adjudicating disputes from the last century - Trevor Drury

CIA: Careers in Adjudication - Panel Discussion

No frolicking and within his jurisdiction - West Midlands Branch Inaugural Event

Welcome to our new members

 
Editors' Notes

Douglas James (4 New Square)

This edition offers eight articles covering the usually wide range of issues. 

Four articles touch on the very practical concerns of calculating days, VAT and adjudicators fees. Seán Bradley considers the old case of Zoan v Rouamba and how it can help clarify timings under the HGCRA. John Littler encourages adjudicators to steer clear of determining VAT disputes. Julian Critchlow of Costigan King analyses the court’s generous approach to adjudicators’ fees. Nick Kaplan of 4 Pump Court explains when (very rarely) one might challenge fees.

Recent British cases have provoked several articles from James O’Donghue (Luett & O’Donoghue) and Arran Dowling-Hussey (4-5 Gray’s inn Square) on the Irish decision in In All Tenderbids, from Jim Armstrong of JS Held on Placefirst v CAR, and from Sylvia Walemba of HS2 and Matthew Cookson and Kate Kenneally of Hill Dickinson on RTI v MUR Shipping. 

Gareth Williams of JWE Williams offers his reflections on the advantages of tiered adjudications, in the (eternal) hope that there might be a better and more efficient way of adjudicating “sprawling and complex” disputes. 

Fenwick Elliott’s distillation of Case Notes keeps readers up to date with the latest caselaw.

Meanwhile, there are updates from the events in London, the South-West, Yorkshire and the East Midlands.

We are grateful for all contributions. Please contact Bernadette Barker if you wish to contribute to the next edition. 

Finally, in case you were concerned that the quality of editorship has risen in this edition, rest assured: the Newsletter now has two new co-editors: Ben Mellors of Hawkswell Kilvington and Chantelle Vermeulen, FCIArb. Thanks to them for joining the team (and getting stuck in so quickly).

Have a great summer! 

Douglas James (4 New Square)

Disclaimer

None of the articles in this Newsletter should be relied on as offering legal advice on any specific matter.

^BACK

 
Size Matters

Gareth Williams

Gareth Williams of JWE Williams considers the benefits of tiered adjudications.

Read the full article

^BACK

 
In All Tenderbids

James O’Donoghue and Arran Dowling-Hussey

James O’Donoghue of Bluett and O’Donoghue and Arran Dowling-Hussey of 4-5 Gray’s Inn Square explain the judgment of Garrett Simons J in In All Tenderbids v Electrical Waste Management

Read the full article

^BACK

 
VAT in adjudication

John Littler

John Littler encourages adjudicators not get drawn into VAT disputes.

Read the full article

^BACK

 
Placefirst

Jim Armstrong

Jim Armstrong of JS Held summarises Placefirst v CAR.

Read the full article

^BACK

 
Adjudicators' Entitlement to Fees

Julian Critchlow

Julian Critchlow of Costigan King analyses the court’s approach to adjudicators’ fees.

Read the full article

^BACK

 
Argue Now, Pay Later - The Perils of Withholding Adjudicators’ Fees

Nick Kaplan

Nick Kaplan of 4 Pump Court advises when, and when (extraordinarily) not, to pay adjudicators’ fees.

Read the full article

^BACK

 
When 7-days actually means 6-days...

Seán Bradley

Seán Bradley considers how to count days under the HGCRA.

Read the full article

^BACK

 
Adapt or Walk Away? Rethinking Force Majeure in a World of Disruption

S. Walemba, M. Cookson and K. Kenneally

Sylvia Walemba of HS2 and Matthew Cookson and Kate Kenneally of Hill Dickinson discuss force majeure through the lens of RTI v MUR Shipping.

Read the full article

^BACK

 
Case Notes

Case Note Contributors: Nicholas Gould, Caitlin Binns and Oliver Weisemann, Fenwick Elliott

Midas Construction Ltd v Harmsworth Pension Funds Trustees Ltd

Reference: [2025] EWHC 1122 (TCC)
Date: 9 May 2025
Judge: Martin Bowdery K.C.
Keywords: Adjudicators' decisions; Administration; Design and Build Sub-Contract; Enforcement; Security for costs

Read the full case note

Lapp Industries Ltd v 1st Formations Ltd

Reference: [2025] EWHC 943 (TCC)
Date: 16 April 2025
Judge: Adrian Williamson KC
Keywords: Adjudicators' decisions; Construction contracts; Jurisdiction; Natural justice; Summary judgments

Read the full case note

Grove Construction (London) Ltd v Bagshot Manor Ltd

Reference: [2024] EWHC 591 (TCC)
Date: 13 March 2025
Judge: District Judge Baldwin
Keywords: Adjudication; Assignment; Construction contracts; Enforcement; Summary judgments

Read the full case note

^BACK

 
Construction Law

Professor John Uff CBE KC introduces the 14th edition of Construction Law

Read the full article

^BACK

 
The Law of Net Zero and Nature Positive

A pioneering work of environmental law, edited by N. Pleming et al.

Read the full article

^BACK

 
Building Women

Faye Allen’s call to action on behalf of women in the construction workforce.

Read the full press release

^BACK

 
13th Case Law Update

Carly Thorpe introduces January's case law update.

Read the full report

^BACK

 
Is the Adjudication Process Unfair?

A summary of a panel discussion in London hosted by BCLP.

Read the full report

^BACK

 
Adjudicating disputes from the last century

Trevor Drury summarises a lecture given in Bristol by David Pliener KC and Andrew Kearney.

Read the full report

^BACK

 
CIA: Careers in Adjudication

A summary of a panel discussion hosted by CMS in Sheffield.

Read the full report

^BACK

 
No frolicking and within his jurisdiction

Summary of the inaugural W. Midlands branch event hosted by Gowling WLG, with pictures.

Read the full report

^BACK

 
Welcome to our new members

A warm welcome to the 45 new full members and 5 student members who have joined the Society since the last newsletter.

Full members

  • Dr Philip Antino, APA Property Services Limited
  • Chris Ashman
  • Diarmuid Bairead, Turner & Townsend PLC
  • Darren Bird, Tarmac Ltd
  • Alison Carroll
  • Himmet Chadha
  • James Collins, JCS Project Services
  • Michael Crawley, Precision Planning
  • Matt Danby, Secretariat
  • Ahmed Elkordy, GBsqd
  • Dalton Hale, Atkin Chambers
  • Vandad Hamidi, Vinci
  • Lindsay Hammond, Gowling WLG (UK) LLP
  • Kerry Higgins, Macfarlanes LLP
  • Thomas Ho
  • Daniel Hostein, Accuracy
  • Peter Huck, Kroll - Expert Services (London)
  • Tom Hutchison, HFW
  • Ahmed Jassam, Secretariat
  • Alun Jones, Alun Jones Ltd
  • Joanne Lacey, Derry Building Services Limited
  • Olivia Maurier, Gowling WLG (UK) LLP
  • Callum Mcsharry, Turner & Townsend Contract Services
  • Ben Mellors, Hawkswell Kilvington
  • Josh Mills, GBsqd
  • Carl Morris, Diales
  • Mick Mullarkey, RG Group
  • Eoin O'Connor
  • Annie O'Sullivan, Gowling WLG (UK) LLP
  • Joseph Kwesi Mfarfo Oddei, MFA Consult
  • Tayo Okunade, Accuracy
  • Will Parker, Brabners LLP
  • Lucy Pearson, Berwick Law Ltd
  • Richard Perry, Voloco LLP
  • Michael Renwick, Precision Consultancy NW Ltd
  • Angelyn Rowan, Philip Lee Solicitors
  • Sinead Sharkey, OneBore Ltd
  • Jon Shaw, 3 PB barristers
  • Robert Sheppard, Tytherleigh-West
  • Matthew Shotton, Hawkswell Kilvington
  • Erin Slater, Turner & Townsend
  • Anne Thompson, CMS Cameron McKenna Nabarro Olswang LLP
  • Julian Thorpe, Bay Quantity Surveyors Ltd
  • Helen Waddell, Pinsent Masons London
  • John Walsh, Senate Consulting

Student members

  • Andrew Ellis, University of Portsmouth
  • Mark Garbus, Government Commercial Office
  • Samantha King, University College of Estate Management
  • Abdurrachman Mappuji, Royal Holloway University of London
  • Gaurav Sarin, King's College London

^BACK